|
|
|
| |
|
Color Coding
Comment by SDA Library
Comment by Critic
Indicates a new thought
Readers wishing to contribute to
this study should please link their comment to the relevant paragraph
or thought number. |
|
|
|
|
Further Discussion Regarding
The Timing of Chapters 4 & 5
1-1-1:
CRITIC:
Remember, there are three applications to the
seven churches:
1) Seven literal churches in
Asia minor
(1st
Application)
2) Seven phases of the Christian era
(2nd Application)
3) All of God’s people today
(3rd Application)
SDA LIBRARY: Quite
so, but the throne room scene of chapters 4 and 5 does not have multiple
applications. According to the way I see it, and according to Uriah Smith
(D&R 375), this scene took place during or after 1844 (see
quote below). As such, the throne room scene still takes place
after
the seventh church has developed its distinctive character in either the 1st
or the 2nd application.
1-1-2:
CRITIC: John has
just penned the messages to the seven churches, not just Laodicea.
[True, but he did pen the message to Laodicea last].
Actually, he has just seen the vision of the churches,
not just the last church.
[True, but we can safely assume that he saw the vision regarding Laodicea last.]
The things that must take place after this refers, in my
opinion, to all that is to come in general not the order of events taking place
directly after the Laodicean era.
Points (1) to (4)
below show clearly that John is speaking of the order
of events taking place after Laodicea has developed its distinctive character.
(1) In 4:1, the
invitation is extended to John: "[a] Come up here, and [b] I will show you what
must take place after this." Then 4:2 reads “At once
I was in the Spirit,
and there before me was a throne in heaven with someone sitting on it.” The
words “at once” in 4:2 are translated “immediately” or “instantly”
in other versions. There is no question, therefore, that 4:2 is an immediate or
instantaneous follow-on to the invitation in part [a] of 4:1, “come up here.”
This means that 4:2 to 5:14 can only be a direct follow-on to the undertaking in
part [b] of 4:1, “I will show you what must take place after this.” Whatever
John is shown in 4:2 to 5:14 (and on), therefore, constitutes the specific
events that “must take place” after “these things.” In this light, it is clear
that John is not here invited to view “all that is to come in general,” but
rather to view specific events that take place at some time after Laodicea has
developed its distinctive character. This is further confirmed below.
CRITIC: That
is true if you assume application number 2 and disregard application 1. However,
if applications 1 is valid, then we have as much reason to apply what is to come
to events following the messages to the literal churches in Asia minor.
Whether we
consider application 1 or 2, the Investigative Judgment that began in 1844 is, in
either case, “what must take place after this.” The throne room scene has a
singular fulfillment during or after 1844 that applies to and fits either application. As
you rightly state
below, “this is a throne room scene taking place
at one point in time.”
So
far I have tried to avoid referring to Uriah Smith, but seeing that you are now
trying to support your position by referring to his views, and to EGW's
endorsement of his views, I must point out that Uriah sees the throne room
meeting of chapters 4 and 5 as taking place in 1844.
"Particular
attention must be given to the fact that the four and twenty elders are said to
be seated on thrones [4:4]. These four and twenty elders are evidently
assistants of Christ in His mediatorial work in the sanctuary on high. When the
judgment scene described in Daniel 7:9 began in the most holy place [in 1844], their
thrones were placed there, according to the testimony of the passage.” (D&R,
p.375 – cf. 98.1+2)
More than
this, AA585.3
seems to indicate that the 2nd application is the primary application that is
here being referred to. This is confirmed by the fact that 3:8 refers to the
open door into the Most Holy place - which door was only opened in 1844 and
which door has no counterpart in the apostolic age.
(2) Strong’s and a
number of translations suggest that 4:1 could [or should] have been translated,
“After these things [5023 tauta - ie. specific events]. . . I was shown
what must take place after these things [5023 tauta - ie. specific
events].” Looking back on chapters 2-3, therefore, John is
focusing our attention on specific events. Then 7:1 opens with the same words,
“After these things [5023 tauta -ie. specific events].”
Looking
back on chapters 4-6, therefore, we see that John is still focusing our
attention on specific events. Clearly, therefore, from 2:1 to 6:17 John is
speaking of specific events and, as such, there is no valid reason why we should
assume that in 4:1 Jesus is merely inviting him to view “all that is to come in
general.”
CRITIC: Both
in Rev. 4:1 and 7:1 John is simply saying that after these things (vision of the
churches) I saw or was shown more things that would come in the future. The
repeat in 4:1, "thing which must be hereafter" can be tricky and throw
you off if you're not careful
[on what basis do you say this?],
but there is no reason to assume that it means that everything in
chapters 4&5 follows in direct historical succession to application number 2 of
the seven churches. That is just too much of a leap, at least for me.
A Leap?: Is it really "a leap" having to believe that
“after this I was shown what is to take place
after this,” does
not mean “after this I was shown what is to take place
before
this?”
Tricky?
Yes, to repeat, it is very tricky indeed when we have to trick our better
judgement into believing that
"after this" actually
means
"before
this." You are quite entitled to claim that this is "tricky," but
then you have to at least substantiate your claim.
No
reason?
There is an abundance of biblical and logical evidence and, sadly, you are just turning a
blind eye to it all. In fact, all we have to do is to read the text as it reads,
which is all that God expects of us.
Sincerely,
you are not being very convincing, or Biblical, or logical in this instance. In fact you are
almost persuading me that God takes delight in confusing us. I have read the
Bible many times over, and almost everything EGW has written, and nowhere else am I
asked to believe that black is white, or that “after this” actually means “before
this?”
CRITIC: Other
verses such as Rev 18:1 and 19:1 use the same basic phrase "and after these
things" to introduce us to another vision.
Precisely,
but 4:1 is different. The vision in 4:1 is the only one that connects what John has just
seen with
what he saw next. The “after this” in 18:1 and 19:1, as it is with the
first “after this” in 4:1, refers to the timing of the vision relative to what
he had just seen in vision - with no specific
reference to the timing of what he saw next, but 4:1 is unique in that it states specifically
that what he saw next would take place after what he had just seen – that is,
after this he saw
what must take place after Laodicea had developed its unique character.
It is really as simple as that.
Then, if John is
here
writing about specific events, we can safely
assume that he is presenting these
events to us “in their order?”
CRITIC: That
is definitely an assumption.
And not a good one based on the rest of the book of Revelation.
Yes,
that’s why I use the word “assume”
above.
Are
you saying, therefore, that we should expect God's prophets to
present specific events "out of order?"
Your last sentence
above is an
unsupported, sweeping statement that unjustifiably elevates you to a seat of
authority - and it carries no weight.
Again, you are quite entitled to make such claims but you have to substantiate
them if they are to be worth anything. This time round you are leaning on
phrases like the above, and terms like "biblical" and "unbiblical" and
"assumption," and yet you have hardly supplied any additional biblical evidence.
:-)
(3) The crucial
point here, however, is that the events recorded in 4:1 – 6:2, whether they are
“specific” or “general,” have a post-1844 timeframe (a point that I believe I
have adequately proven above and below) – which makes it very difficult to
believe that the white horse of 6:2 represents a triumphant church in the first
century A.D.
CRITIC: I will
have to look at how you have proven this before making any comments here.
(4) We have
accepted a specific order of events in Chapters 2 and 3 (2nd
application), and we have accepted a specific order of events in 4:1 to 6:2. In
the light of the evidence presented above and below, it is not difficult to
accept 4:1 as a time-link between these two passages – especially when a
straightforward reading of the verse suggests that this is the case?
CRITIC: The
order of events does not apply to applications 1 and 3 and it is not necessary.
Neither is it necessary in chapters 4 and 5 as this is a throne room scene
taking place at one point in time.
Please notice
that I speak of 4:1 to 6:2 not just of 4 and 5 - we are trying to pinpoint the
timing of 6:2 and, seeing that 4 and 5 introduce us to 6:2, the order of events
in chapters 4 and 5 is of vital importance. Please bear in mind that our primary
concern here is with application 2 - because application 2 makes no sense if we
accept our traditional interpretation..
Uriah Smith
certainly sees significance in the order of events.
“This song
[of the 24 elders in chapter 5:9] is sung before any of the events in the
prophecy of the seven seals take place.” (Daniel and the
Revelation, p.374)
And, please
note that, according to Uriah, this song was sung in 1844.
Nevertheless,
isn’t
Uriah speaking of an order of events above? Sure he is. Doesn’t the throne room
vision deal with an order of events? Sure it does. And does this not support my
view that the events of chapters 4 and 5 take place before the seven seals are
loosed? Sure it does. And if Uriah uses terms such as “before any of the
events,” and John uses terms such as “after this” (twice in 4:1) are we not
being presented with an important order of events?
1-1-4:
CRITIC:
Personally I do not see the events of chapters 4&5
taking place after either application.
I refer you
to point
(1) above.
More than this,
I fail to see how you can say this when John states explicitly, and in summary,
“After this . . . I was shown
what must take place after this? – and when 4:2
makes it abundantly clear that 4:2 and on are precisely what follows “after
this” (see point
(2)
above).
Then, of
course, the only way that chapters 4 and 5 can take place “after” both
application 1 and application 2 is if the events of chapters 4 and 5 take place during or
after 1844 – which is the main point
I am making, and which point Uriah agrees with.
1-1-5:
CRITIC:
To me
these chapters [4&5] emphasize the cross and what was achieved there by Christ.
Once again,
please notice that Uriah Smith does not entirely agree with you:
“This song
[of the 24 elders in chapter 5:9] is sung before any of the events in the
prophecy of the seven seals take place; for it is sung to set forth [a] the
worthiness of the Lamb to take the book and to open the seals [b] on the ground
of what He has already accomplished – their redemption.” (Daniel and the
Revelation, p.374 – figures in square brackets my own)
I agree with
Uriah in that chapters 4 & 5 emphasize the worthiness of Father and Son – and
this in the light of (a) creation - where He
gave life to us
(4:11) and (b) the cross - where He gave His life to us
(5:9). Seeing that the word “worthy” appears in 4:11, 5:2, 5:9, & 5:12, and
based on the general focus of chapters 4 and 5, we cannot deny that the cross is
central to the scene in Chapters 4 and 5, but the primary emphasis is clearly
on God’s worthiness in the light of creation and the cross.
1-1-6:
CRITIC:
Most
of the scenes [in chapters 4 and 5] took place some time in the context of His ascension and
symbolically describe His victory in redeeming this planet from sin by His blood
thus preparing the way for the unleashing of the gospel (white horse) to go
forth as never before conquering and to conquer.
Once again
you need to substantiate your claim. According to straightforward Scriptural evidence, and according to Uriah Smith,
these scenes take place at some time after 1844. Uriah, states clearly that this
is the investigative judgment. (D&R, p.375 - see
quote above)
To enlarge on
what is stated above, the primary
focus here is on the worthiness of God because only a worthy God could receive
the sanction from all in the throne room (see 5:11-12) to unleash fearful judgments
(four horses, plagues etc) on the earth. The prophetic preview in 5:13 further
satisfies all in the throne room that following after these judgments “every creature which is in heaven and on
the earth” will still bow down and acknowledge the worthiness of the Father and the
Son – and this in spite of these judgments which will then be history. In this context please consider the
following statement.
`Much
excellent labor was bestowed upon the Laodicean church.
. . .
But the church did not follow
up the work begun by God's messengers. They heard, but they failed to
appropriate the truth to themselves, and to carry out the instruction given
them. The result that followed
is the result always sure to follow the rejection of the Lord's warnings and
entreaties.’ (MS 128, 1903)
As it was
back then, so it is today. We are
presently
reaping the first "sprinklings" of that
result (2nd and 3rd application) . . .
To conclude
this discussion, I include a few extracts from various commentaries and
translations - with the pertinent portions
highlighted.
`John saw a
door . . . open in heaven and heard a voice inviting him, Come up here, and I
will show you what must take place after this. The words “what must take place
after this” are similar to those in 1:19, “what will take place later.” Whereas
1:19 indicates that the events will take place later, in 4:1b the Greek word dei
is used, which means that the events must occur. This points not only to the
future but also to the sovereign purpose of God. The similarity of the two
expressions confirms the threefold chronological outline given in 1:19.
Both the revelation and its
fulfillment are chronologically subsequent to chapters 1-3. (Walvoord,
J. F., Zuck, R. B., & Dallas Theological Seminary. 1983-c1985. The Bible
Knowledge Commentary : An exposition of the scriptures on Revelation 4:1. Victor
Books: Wheaton, IL)
`After this I
saw, and, behold, a door in heaven was standing open, and there came to me the
voice that I had heard before, speaking to me like the sound of a trumpet, and
the speaker said: “Come up here, and I will show you
the events
which must follow these things.” (The Revelation of John : Volume 1.
2000, c1976 (W. Barclay, lecturer in the University of Glasgow, Ed.). The Daily
study Bible series, Rev. ed. The Westminster Press: Philadelphia)
Should my
reader wish to contribute to this discussion, please
click
here to send an email. Should you wish to make an extensive contribution
then press Edit, Select All and copy this entire page to MS WORD. Now, in the
resultant MS WORD document, you may insert your comments into the copy in a
unique color and then save this document as REV1-1 and attach it to the email
above before sending it. TO ENSURE THAT YOUR EMAIL IS NOT REJECTED AS SPAM, PLEASE ENTER THE
WORDS "REVELATION INSIGHTS" IN THE SUBJECT LINE OF YOUR EMAIL.
|